Skip to main content

Cheapest Budget Commander Decks, Priced Card by Card

EDHREC's budget lists aren't all cheap. We added up every card to find which ones are.

6 min readBy Reid MarshLast reviewed

Verdict

Krenko, Mob Boss is the cheapest real budget Commander deck we priced: $40.08 for the whole deck at the cheapest printings, with no card above $5. Six more stay under $75, and Liliana the Repentant has dropped into second. Two of the new Reality Fracture commanders are the trap: Liliana the Faultless and Niv-Mizzet, Ghost Counsel both cost over $100 in their budget versions.

Niv-Mizzet, Ghost Counsel, Liliana the Faultless, Liliana the Repentant, and Lathril, Blade of the Elves fanned out against a dark background

The cheapest of the budget Commander decks we priced is Krenko, Mob Boss: EDHREC's budget list for him comes to $40.08 at Scryfall's cheapest non-foil printings, with no card over $5. Liliana the Repentant is the only other one under fifty dollars, and seven of the 10 commanders we checked stay under $75, which is about what we'd call budget today.

How we got there: on EDHREC, "budget" is a filter, not a price tag. So we took its budget average deck for each of 10 commanders, priced every card on Scryfall and added them up, first on October 13, 2026 and again on October 19. Basic lands weren't counted, since most players already have a pile. If you have a hard $50 cap and want a deck built to fit it, our budget Commander decks under $50 guide shows what to cut from the Lathril and Wilhelt lists to get there.

Bar chart of EDHREC budget average deck costs on October 19, 2026: Krenko, Mob Boss $40.08, Liliana the Repentant $48.40, T'Challa $56.81, Chulane $58.17, Wilhelt $58.70, Lathril $67.50, Doctor Doom $73.71, and over $100 for Edgar Markov, Liliana the Faultless and Niv-Mizzet, Ghost Counsel Image: BaseMTG chart. Data: EDHREC budget average decks and Scryfall prices, October 19, 2026.

CommanderBudget deck cost (Oct 19)EDHREC decks (Oct 20)Priciest card in the list
Krenko, Mob Boss$40.0844,642Goblin Chieftain, $4.65
Liliana the Repentant$48.40648Crypt of Agadeem, $3.71
T'Challa, the Black Panther$56.814,618Birds of Paradise, $6.90
Chulane, Teller of Tales$58.179,725Scute Swarm, $8.43
Wilhelt, the Rotcleaver$58.7022,802Wilhelt itself, $9.96
Lathril, Blade of the Elves$67.5036,161Elvish Promenade, $8.10
Doctor Doom, King of Latveria$73.7111,280Black Market Connections, $11.20

None of the 10 budget lists runs a single card from the Game Changers list, so by card list alone every one of them can sit in Bracket 2. All 10 still play Sol Ring.

What changed in a week

Two decks swapped places. Liliana the Repentant's average list got cheaper as more people built it: it went from 550 EDHREC decks to 630, Liliana, Heretical Healer dropped out of the average, and the deck fell from $54.44 to $48.40. Its priciest card is now Crypt of Agadeem at $3.71, so it's the only list here where nothing costs even four dollars. Chulane went the other way, from $51.27 to $58.17, because Scute Swarm ($8.43) moved into the average list. Six of the other eight moved by under two dollars. Liliana the Faultless fell a little more, and Niv-Mizzet, Ghost Counsel's list dropped about ten dollars and is still the priciest of the 10.

The seven cheapest budget Commander decks

1. Krenko, Mob Boss ($40.08). One ability: tap to create a 1/1 Goblin for each Goblin you control. That doubles every turn Krenko survives, which is why it's in more EDHREC decks than any other budget deck here except Edgar. Goblins have been printed since the first set, and nothing in the budget list costs $5. We'd start here if you want one deck that wins games without much thought.

2. Liliana the Repentant ($48.40). The cheapest new commander from Reality Fracture. It costs {1}{B}, mills two whenever another creature or planeswalker of yours enters, and has a once-per-game exhaust ability for {5}{B} that returns a creature or planeswalker from your graveyard to the battlefield. Only a few hundred EDHREC decks so far, so the list is still moving, but it's a self-mill and reanimation deck for under fifty dollars.

Liliana the Repentant card art showing a purple-robed sorceress with glowing magic in both hands standing in a ruined graveyard, with her mill-on-enter and once-per-game reanimation exhaust ability visible Image: Liliana the Repentant card art via Scryfall, © Wizards of the Coast.

3. T'Challa, the Black Panther ($56.81). Selesnya artifacts from Marvel Super Heroes Commander (June 26, 2026). T'Challa makes a tapped Vibranium token when it enters or attacks and gets two +1/+1 counters whenever you cast an artifact with mana value 4 or more. If you'd rather start from the precon, see our Wakanda Forever upgrade guide.

4. Chulane, Teller of Tales ($58.17). Bant creatures. Every creature spell draws a card and lets you put a land from your hand onto the battlefield, and Chulane can bounce your own creatures to recast them. Scute Swarm is now the most expensive card in the budget list, ahead of Chulane.

5. Wilhelt, the Rotcleaver ($58.70). Zombies that come back as 2/2 decayed tokens when they die, plus a sacrifice-and-draw at your end step. The commander is the single priciest card, just under ten dollars, which says a lot about how cheap Zombies are. The under-$50 guide linked above has the full Wilhelt and Lathril decklists.

6. Lathril, Blade of the Elves ($67.50). Elves with menace on the commander: Lathril makes an Elf Warrior for each point of combat damage, and tapping ten Elves drains each opponent for 10 while you gain 10. The Elf payoffs push the cost up, with Elvish Promenade, Elven Ambush and Elderfang Venom all above $6.

7. Doctor Doom, King of Latveria ($73.71). Grixis Villains, also from Marvel Super Heroes Commander. Discarding lands drains each opponent for 2, and Doom makes a Villain connive every combat. Black Market Connections at $11.20 is the most expensive card in any of the seven lists. Our Doom Prevails upgrade guide covers the precon version.

GODEEPER: None of these lists runs a Game Changer, but bracket is about speed too. Commander Brackets explained →, or run a list through the Commander bracket calculator.

The three that missed

The surprise was the new cards. Liliana the Faultless's budget list costs $103.74 and Niv-Mizzet, Ghost Counsel's costs $108.49, even though the commanders themselves are $5.52 and $4.08. Both lists are built from a long run of $5 to $10 cards, topped by Ajani Resolute ($11.09) in each. Edgar Markov's list is $102.74, and $27.27 of that is Edgar.

Niv-Mizzet, Ghost Counsel card art showing a blue dragon looming over a group of cloaked figures on a temple staircase Image: Niv-Mizzet, Ghost Counsel card art via Scryfall, © Wizards of the Coast.

These averages are built from few decks so far: on October 20, 824 for Liliana the Faultless and 4,626 for Niv-Mizzet. We'd wait a few weeks for the lists to settle, or swap the priciest cards for cheaper ones yourself.

What players are saying

On r/EDH on October 11, someone asked which tribe to build on a budget. One reply lined up with our numbers: "Goblins can be very cheap, Sphinxes are still very cheap, Dinosaurs can be cheap, birds, spirits, zombies and Shrines are all cheap". And for a new player worried about the cost of the whole hobby, the top answer in another thread was shorter: "Just keep proxying."

Really Bad At MTG's June video asks the same question from the other side, which $50 Commander deck is the strongest:

Our take

Of the budget Commander decks we priced, Krenko is the one we'd build first. It's the cheapest list, wins in a way new players understand, and everything in it is under $5. If you want something less linear, Liliana the Repentant is now the second-cheapest deck here and the only one with nothing above four dollars, and Wilhelt and Chulane both sit just under sixty. We'd skip the budget lists for the two pricier new commanders for now: Liliana the Faultless and Niv-Mizzet cost about twice what Liliana the Repentant does, for reasons that have nothing to do with the commander. Whatever you pick, start with the basics of a first deck, and count your basic lands too: the lists run from 17 in Doom's to 34 in Krenko's.

How we checked this: on October 13, 2026 we downloaded EDHREC's budget average deck for each of the 10 commanders, priced every card at its cheapest non-foil printing on Scryfall, left out basic lands, and checked each list against Scryfall's Game Changers search. On October 19 we re-downloaded the lists and re-priced every card the same way, and on October 20 we re-read EDHREC's deck counts. Commander abilities are from Scryfall's Oracle text. The scripts and output are kept with our sources.

References

Was this guide helpful?

Enjoyed this?

Share it with other players.

About the author

Reid Marsh

Commander & Budget Desk

Pen name for the BaseMTG Commander desk: budget builds, precons, upgrades and deck-building. Lists are priced from Scryfall on the publish date and every card pick comes with a reason.

  • Commander builds, budget lists and precon upgrades
  • Prices checked on Scryfall, dated in the article
  • A sources table behind every card and number

Disclaimer

This article is published for informational and entertainment purposes. It does not constitute professional financial, legal, or technical advice. Game performance, online services, patch schedules, and store listings change. Verify critical details (pricing, system requirements, regional availability) with publishers and storefronts before you buy. Affiliate links, where present, help support our editorial work and are labelled in our affiliate disclosure.

BaseMTG

Magic: The Gathering news, deck guides, card values, and meta analysis.