Skip to main content

How to Build Your First Commander Deck: Lands, Ramp, Removal

We counted lands, ramp, removal and card draw in the 100 most popular Commander decks. Here's the starting shape they share.

7 min readBy Reid MarshLast reviewed

Verdict

Start with 35 to 36 lands, Sol Ring, Arcane Signet, about 10 removal spells and 10 card draw effects, then spend the rest on your commander's plan. That's the shape EDHREC's average decks for the 100 most popular commanders share: a median of 35 lands, Sol Ring in all 100 and Arcane Signet in 99. If it's your very first deck, buy a precon instead and learn from it.

Sol Ring and Arcane Signet cards side by side, the two mana rocks in nearly every popular Commander deck on EDHREC

To build your first Commander deck, you need a legendary creature as your commander and 99 other cards in its colours, with no two cards sharing a name except basic lands. Everything after that is ratios: how many lands, how much ramp, how many answers.

Most guides give you ranges from experience. We wanted to see what players actually do, so on October 13, 2026 we pulled EDHREC's average deck for each of the 100 commanders on its Top Commanders page and counted every role. The numbers below come from those 100 decks.

The rules you can't skip

The Comprehensive Rules (effective September 25, 2026) set four limits that shape every list:

  • 100 cards exactly, "including its commander".
  • Singleton: "other than basic lands, each card in a commander deck must have a different english name."
  • Colour identity: a card can go in only if every colour in its identity is also in your commander's. Hybrid and colour symbols in rules text count. Our colour identity guide covers the edge cases.
  • The game itself: each player's "starting life total is 40", and each recast of your commander from the command zone "costs an additional {2}" per previous cast (how the commander tax works).

How many lands?

Histogram of land counts in EDHREC average decks for the 100 most popular commanders: 22 run 34 lands, 29 run 35, 28 run 36, with a range from 28 to 41 Image: BaseMTG chart. Data: EDHREC Top Commanders and average decks, October 13, 2026.

The median is 35. Of the 100 decks, 79 play 34, 35 or 36 lands, and only 13 play 37 or more. The extremes make sense: Kinnan, Bonder Prodigy doubles mana from nonland permanents, so its deck plays 28 lands and more mana rocks. Hearthhull, the Worldseed sacrifices lands to draw cards, so its deck plays 41.

For a first deck we'd go one higher than the median, to 36. You'll have fewer mana rocks than a tuned list, and missing your third land drop loses more games than drawing one land too many.

The two cards every deck plays

Sol Ring is in all 100 average decks. Arcane Signet is in 99; the one exception is Zhulodok, Void Gorger, a colourless commander. Command Tower is in 93, and all seven decks without it have a mono-coloured or colourless commander, where it does little a basic land doesn't.

Sol Ring, a colorless artifact that costs 1 and taps for 2 colorless mana Image: Sol Ring card face via Scryfall, © Wizards of the Coast.

Arcane Signet, a colorless artifact that taps for one mana of any color in your commander's color identity Image: Arcane Signet card face via Scryfall, © Wizards of the Coast.

Swords to Plowshares (54 of 100 decks) and Cultivate (48) are the next most common "staples" we checked, and both depend on colour.

Ramp, removal and card draw

Chart of cards per role in the 100 most popular Commander average decks: lands median 35, creatures 29, ramp 16, removal 10, card draw 9, board wipes 2 Image: BaseMTG chart. Data: EDHREC average decks, roles by Scryfall tagger tags, October 13, 2026.

We sorted every non-land card with Scryfall's community tags for ramp, card draw, removal and board wipes. Those tags are broad: a mana creature, a Cultivate and a land-searching creature all count as ramp, and one card can sit in two roles. With that caveat, the medians are:

RoleMedianRange across the 100 decks
Lands3528 to 41
Creatures2915 to 40
Ramp (any kind)166 to 35
Removal104 to 29
Card draw93 to 31
Board wipes20 to 8

Ramp looks higher than the usual "10 ramp" advice because the tag also counts mana creatures and land-searching spells; 85 of the 100 decks have at least 10. Removal and card draw sit right around 10. Ten of the 100 decks run no board wipe at all.

So the shape we'd start from: 36 lands, 10 or more ramp pieces (Sol Ring and Arcane Signet first), 10 removal including two board wipes, and 10 card draw. That leaves about 40 slots for your commander's plan, and many of those can do two jobs at once. If you'd rather the commander do the drawing, start from our best card draw commanders. For the eight single-target answers, our best removal in Commander tier list ranks the most-played ones by color.

GODEEPER: Which board wipe fits your deck depends on what you play. Board wipes explained →

Pick a commander, then a plan

The average decks above are for popular commanders, and popularity is a decent filter for a first deck. Krenko, Mob Boss was in 44,682 EDHREC decks on October 21, 2026, and does one thing: tap to make Goblins equal to the Goblins you have. Commanders like that teach you the format without a page of rules text. If you're choosing colors before a commander, our MTG color combinations guide shows what each pair and trio plays like and how deep its commander pool runs.

Write one sentence before you pick cards: how does this deck win? "Make a wide board of Goblins and attack" is a plan. "Play good cards" isn't. Every card should either push that plan, protect it, answer something that stops it, or draw you into it.

If you'd rather not build from scratch, buy a precon. Wizards' original bracket guidance put the average modern precon at Bracket 2, but the October 2025 update dropped that link because precons vary too much, so check each deck's own list. A precon comes with lands, ramp and removal already in place. Play it a few times, note which cards sat in your hand, and change five or ten at a time. Our budget Commander decks roundup prices ten full lists, the cheapest at $40.08.

Talk to the table

Before your first game, say what your deck does and how fast it wins. The Commander Brackets give you the words for it.

On r/EDH, a player asking how to fix a first three-colour mana base got this tip: "Moxfield has a really great tool down below the deck lists." And in a thread about keeping new players happy, the top reply had the simplest test of whether your deck is the problem: "Offer to play their decks and they play yours."

The Commander's Quarters' March 2026 guide walks through a full first build:

Our take

When you build your first Commander deck, copy the shape, not the cards. Thirty-six lands, Sol Ring, Arcane Signet, 10 answers and 10 ways to draw cards will keep almost any first deck functional, and the 100 most popular decks on EDHREC aren't far from that. The hard part is the remaining 40 slots, and that's where your deck becomes yours. If you can't decide what goes there, a precon is the cheapest way to find out what you like.

How we checked this: on October 13, 2026 we downloaded EDHREC's average deck for each of the 100 commanders on its Top Commanders page, took land and creature counts from EDHREC, classified the other cards with Scryfall's tagger tags (otag:ramp, otag:draw, otag:removal, otag:board-wipe), and checked the rules against the Comprehensive Rules dated September 25, 2026. The script and data are kept with our sources.

References

Was this guide helpful?

Enjoyed this?

Share it with other players.

About the author

Reid Marsh

Commander & Budget Desk

Pen name for the BaseMTG Commander desk: budget builds, precons, upgrades and deck-building. Lists are priced from Scryfall on the publish date and every card pick comes with a reason.

  • Commander builds, budget lists and precon upgrades
  • Prices checked on Scryfall, dated in the article
  • A sources table behind every card and number

Disclaimer

This article is published for informational and entertainment purposes. It does not constitute professional financial, legal, or technical advice. Game performance, online services, patch schedules, and store listings change. Verify critical details (pricing, system requirements, regional availability) with publishers and storefronts before you buy. Affiliate links, where present, help support our editorial work and are labelled in our affiliate disclosure.

BaseMTG

Magic: The Gathering news, deck guides, card values, and meta analysis.